Piecing Together the Story of Lottie L. Tillotson

Posted on: March 17, 2021

By Alejandra Gaeta, Associate Archivist/Librarian

“Little is known about Lottie Tillotson.”

It was that first sentence that caught my attention and that ultimately led me down the rabbit hole of research. It is such an unusual statement to have written in a finding aid, a document that is meant to provide a summary of succinct facts that is useful for researchers. (A finding aid is a document that provides information about archival collections, including biographical information of the people it involves, descriptions of the types of materials it contains and how the collection is arranged.) This brief statement is factual—the Autry Archive and Library did not have much information about Lottie as a person. Although the Lottie L. Tillotson Collection includes photographs she took, it does not include personal papers, such as letters, that might provide some insight into Lottie’s personal life.

Intrigued, I decided to look her up online. The collection was processed, and the finding aid published, in 2002—thus enough time had passed that there might be additional digitized material available online that wouldn’t have been accessible almost twenty years ago. Right away, I found mostly entries related to the Autry but then a link to a digitized newspaper caught my attention. I was surprised to find that Lottie’s name was in hundreds of newspapers—mostly in notices advertising her speaking engagements. However, there were also some interesting pieces written about her, including arrests, accusations of theft, and even her deportation from Canada in 1917.

Lottie began her elocutionary career in the late 1890s, traveling from the Midwest to the Southwest and initially identified as “Miss Lottie L. Tillotson of St. Paul, Minn.” Sometime in 1906, she became, “Lottie L. Tillotson, Hawaiian Entertainer” claiming to have lived “among the Hawaiians for years” and established a career lecturing on “their habits and customs.” Although it did seem that Lottie had visited Hawaii, it was clear that it was at most a few months since several newspapers advertised her elocutionary events in the Midwest. At this point, I was caught in the vortex of research—caught by the problematic nature of her assumed identity of an expert on Hawaiian culture, the mixture of praise, criticism, and instances of theft reported—and, overall, by her unusual lifestyle for a woman of the early 20th century. Lottie traveled alone, supporting herself as a public speaker and actively documenting her travels through her collection of photographs and souvenir publications. She continued traveling into her 70s; her name (including her middle name, Lucinda!) was on passenger manifests from ships sailing back to the U.S. from Japan, New Zealand, and Argentina. This was also how I found her birthdate (May 6, 1862) and learned that she had been born in Buffalo, Minnesota. Her death certificate was also online, which documented Lottie’s death in Los Angeles on August 13, 1948 at the age of 86.

After tracking her life through the newspapers and paperwork available online, I looked through her collection of photographs and found her handwriting on almost every single one. Usually, the photographs had her name, always including her middle initial (her elegant L’s sometimes appearing as a letter S), but at times, there was additional text such as the date she visited or descriptive information about the locations or people photographed. Lottie sometimes wrote down small personal details, such as the photograph of the Old Round Tower at Fort Snelling on which she wrote, “Lottie L. Tillotson use to play here when a child,” and the longer snippet she wrote on the back of a photograph of the San Marcos River in Texas:

Visited San Marcos Texas Oct 24th 1894
Took a boat ride on this beautiful river a perfect wonder whose waters are so pure that a pin or small grain of gravel can be seen distinctly laying on the bottom through a depth of water of 40 ft. The beautiful under growth of moss + vegetation from the bottom and the floating flowers on the surface make a beautiful changing panorama at each stroke of the oar.

There are more handwritten notes, hundreds of photographs in her collection to search through to learn more about Lottie and her life. This is barely a peek into Lottie’s history, and it is very tempting to continue this research—to fill out her timeline, to track her travels and gather the pieces of her personality through her own writing and pieces written about her by others. Each piece, from newspaper articles to simple handwritten notes contain stories about Lottie. The stories that make up her life are compelling and provide the perfect example of the draw of the archive—how it leads from breadcrumb to breadcrumb until you’re led deep into the rabbit hole.

Additional Sources:

  • Chronicling America, Library of Congress in partnership with the National Endowment for the Humanities - access to digitized historic American newspapers
  • NewspaperArchive.com - access to additional digitized newspapers (this resource was accessible through the Los Angeles Public Library and may be accessible through your local public library)
  • FamilySearch.org – provided access to U.S. Census records, death records and ship passenger lists (this resource may be accessible through your local public library).

Image Captions

  • Photograph of Lottie L. Tillotson standing on Eagle Rock in the Petrified Forest at Chalcedony Park, Arizona. Note on the back: LLT standing on the top. Visited by Lottie L. Tillotson Oct 30th-31st 1896
  • Image of Lottie L. Tillotson’s newspaper advertisement from the Lake County Independent newspaper, October 2, 1908.
  • Photo of Lake Couer D’Alene with notes from Lottie noting her visits on March 7–8 and April 4–5, 1900.
  • Detail of Lake Couer D’Alene photograph. Along the right-hand side of the photo she wrote: Went sailing with Mrs. Budlong on this lake in her private yacht.
  • Photo titled “The Old Round Tower at Fort Snelling” with Lottie’s note at the top: Lottie L. Tillotson use to play here when a child.
  • Photo of man leading a horse and buggy in front of building with a Hotel sign and a woman holding a child to the left.
  • On the back of the photograph of the hotel, Lottie wrote: Residence of Mrs. J.R. Cook oldest house in Northwestern Neb.
  • Photo labeled “San Marco River below Railroad Bridge, looking N.”
  • Verso of San Marco River image on which Lottie had written rather poetic description of her experience while boating on the river.
  • Photo of snow scene with horse-drawn sled holding two couples. Lottie wrote along the left-hand side and bottom: “Lottie L. Tillotson scene in first Texas First-snow storm for many years.”
  • Photo of the Wyoming Devil’s Tower marked with a small black x.
  • On the back of the Wyoming Devil’s Tower photograph, Lottie explained, “x Point of heights to where I climbed.”
  • California Souvenir of Santa Barbara Mission with one tower marked with a small black x. Lottie wrote along the bottom that she visited March 1897 and “climbed into x Tower.”
  • Photo of a woman sitting at the bottom of a waterfall identified as Hedge Creek Falls near Shasta Springs from note written along the bottom. It’s unclear if Lottie is the woman featured since she did not include a name as she seemed to do when she photographed her companions.
  • Photo of a woman sitting in front of a tent.
  • Lottie wrote on the back: “Camp Majella” Camp of Mrs. R.C. Taylor + Lottie L. Tillotson in the Yosemite Valley under the Royal Arches from June 20th to July 19th 1897. Mrs Taylor in the picture.